Discussions Editorial Forum
Editorial Health Reflectons Travel Music & Art Humour
Book Review Column Poetry Prev Issue Next Issue

Monday, June 12, 2000
Two Variants of Raga Bihag and Thirakhwa's Tabla Solo
Rajan P. Parrikar

Rajan P. Parrikar is a recognized expert on Indian Classical Music and shares his knowledge freely with those interested in the subject.
He has written a series of articles on Indian Classical Music some of which have been archived on Sawf. Click here to read Rajan's archived articles.

Namashkar.

In this feature two variants of Raga Bihag, namely, Bihagda and Pat Bihag, are addressed. I expect to keep the commentary terse and precise. Throughout the discussion, M = shuddha madhyam and m = teevra madhyam. At the end of this article, an unpublished 1964 Pune mehfil recording of the great Tabla maestro Ahmad Jan 'Thirakhwa' is offered.


Raga Bihagda

The key idea in this rAga is the introduction of the komal nishAd into the Bihag flow. This is accomplished chiefly through two tonal sentences of the type:

G M n D P, G M G
G M P D n D P, G M G

Raga Bihagda may thus be seen as an offshoot of Bihag with strands of Khamaj spliced in. Although the influence of Bihag preponderates, a few special prayogas carve out an independent identity for Bihagda. To wit,

S G, GMPMP G (R)S
S G M D, D P, GMPMP G, D M P N, N S"

As in Bihag, the gandhAr is very strong (nyAsa swara); so is the nishAd. Similarly the measured avarohi glide from G to S grazing R en route is inspired by Bihag. Likewise the movement from N to P. The teevra madhyam is eliminated or rendered weak (alpatva) in almost all treatments. With this brief and essential background we now march into the audio theatre. There we shall have opportunities aplenty to isolate and examine the deployment of the komal nishAd.

In the mid-1960s Jitendra Abhisheki composed a magnificent Marathi Natyageeta based in Bihagda for YAYATI-DEVAYANI and then callously handed it over to amcho Ramdas Kamat to molest. Ramdas-bab's tAns remind us of the first cries of a freshly-baked baby struggling to cope with life outside the amnion. I have masterfully edited the clip to spare you the trauma: mee mAnApamAnA -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/kamat.ram


Bade Ghulam Ali Khan's approach retains a strong Bihag presence, including graces of the teevra madhyam. This, from an unpublished mehfil -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/bgak_vil.ram


A variety of strategies and ucchAraNa is observed in the clusters laden with the komal nishAd. For instance, Shaila Datar sings a composition of the late Master Krishnarao that is sparing in its use of the komal nishAd. Also note some of the peculiarities in the poorvAnga -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/datar.ram


The gifted musician and composer of the Khurja Gharana, Zahoor Khan, is not a familiar name to the current generation of rasikas. He was a polyglot comfortable in Sanskrit, Braja, Farsi and Urdu. Trained by Tanras Khan, he adopted the mudrA 'Ramdas' for his Braja poetry and 'Mumkin' as his Urdu takhallus. Prabhudeo Sardar presents a beautiful vilambit Khayal composed by him: mA'i ri -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/sardar_vil.ram


Prabhudeo Sardar took tAleem from Jagannathbuwa Purohit ('Gunidas') and next serves the hugely popular cheez of 'Gunidas' composed in honour of the latter's guru Vilayat Hussain Khan: sakhi mandarwA, Aye nahiN preetam pyAre -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/sardar_druta.ram


The Atrauli-Jaipur musicians have reified Bihagda, elevating it to heights unscaled before their time. We are pleased to have in attendance a battery of the leading lights of that school. Who better to begin with than Alladiya Khan's prized pupil Kesarbai Kerkar? The first half of the clip finds her in a leisurely gait, before her eruption into a cannonade of magnificent tAns. Take stock of the interplay of the two nishAds. The composition is Alladiya Khansahib's favourite: pyAri paga hole -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/kesarbai_bihagda.ram


The next two items figure Alladiya Khan's other star pupil, Mogubai Kurdikar, in an unforgettable display. I would like to draw attention to the explicitly intoned teevra madhyam in this rendition. This is not an across-the-board feature of the Atrauli-Jaipur conception of Bihagda. The phraseology supporting the teevra madhyam advanced by Mogubai briefly creates an AvirbhAva of Raga Nand. The first clip below elaborates on pyAre paga hole, the second is the well-known cheez mohe jAne de -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/mogubai_bihagda_vil.ram

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/mogubai_bihagda_druta.ram


Sardarbai Karadgekar, a disciple of Nathhan Khan (nephew of Alladiya Khansaheb), has her say -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/karadgekar_bihagda.ram


Mallikarjun Mansur reprises the standard Atrauli-Jaipur bandish but with a touch attributed to his guru Manji Khan (son of Alladiya Khansaheb): the placement of the sam on the pancham -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/mansur_bihagda.ram


Tha Jaipur-Atrauli folks also sing a variation of Bihagda, called the "Ek Ni Bihagda," where, as the name suggests, only one nishAd (shuddha) is employed. The brightened (i.e. deergha) dhaivat and its interplay with the shuddha nishAd make for a fascinating discourse. Mallikarjun Mansur's masterful display in this rAga is all too well-known. Notice the beautiful bandish structure and its manner of resolution within the vilambit Jhaptala setting: bairana re -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/mansur_eknibihagda.ram


Unlike her mother Mogubai, Kishori Amonkar takes just one nishAd (shuddha) in in mohe jAne de and delivers her Ek Ni Bihagda in a breathtaking performance. There is nobody in the world today who can sing like this. Verify for yourself -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/kishori_eknibihagda.ram


One seldom hears instrumental renditions in Bihagda. Vilayat Khan tries to generate some enthusiasm but meets with very limited success -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/vilayat.ram


We conclude the Bihagda tableau with an elegant vilambit Khayal composition of Pandit Ramashreya Jha "Ramrang": rasiyA mero -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/jha_bihagda.ram


Raga Pat Bihag

Pat Bihag is developed by appropriately pruning Bihag. That is to say, it comes about through a chalan-bheda on the parent Bihag. Pat Bihag uses all the shuddha swaras (the teevra madhyam may occasionally present itself as a kaN-swara) and most of its mannerisms are Bihag-like. The notable departure is the striking nature of its shuddha madhyam - deergha and mukta. A sample Pat Bihag chalan is formulated below (variations in detail prevail across Gharana boundaries):

S G (R)G M, M, P G, S P G (R)G M
G M P S" P, GMPN (D)N S", S" P, P D M P G (R)G M, P G M G (R)S

This time Jitendra Abhisheki does right, entrusting his beautiful composition for KATYAR KALJAT GHUSLI to Vasantrao Deshpande -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/deshpande.ram


K.G. Ginde improvises on a superb composition of the extraordinary musician, vidwAn, vAggeyakAra and shAstrakAra, Pandit Vishnu Narayan Bhatkhande (his mudrA 'chatura' is embedded in the antarA): sAjana nAye ri -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/ginde_patbihag.ram


The Atrauli-Jaipur musicians purvey a maverick version of Pat Bihag that recruits both the komal gandhAr and the komal nishAd. Kishori Amonkar makes this lamentably clear in an old recording: dhana dhana mangala gA'o -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/kishori_patbihag.ram


Ulhas Kashalkar also has a komal gandhAr tucked into his busy rendition -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/kashalkar_patbihag.ram


We end this brisk tour with a delectable composition of the exceptionally gifted vAggeyakAra and vidwAn, Pandit Ramashreya Jha "Ramrang." His Pat Bihag is conceived differently from the ones preceding (can you see how?): E banA byAhana Ayo -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/jha_patbihag.ram


Ahmad Jan 'Thirakhwa' - solo in Ektal (1964, Pune):

Ahmad Jan 'Thirakhwa' (1891-1976) was the greatest Tabla master of the 20th century. He earned the onomatopoeic sobriquet "Thirakhwa" in his childhood, so the story goes, on account of the magical manner in which his fingers moved over the Tabla. He was formally trained in the Farrukhabad idiom but was a whole, consummate maestro adept in all the major styles. A few moments spent in his company are manna for the soul -

http://www.sawf.org/audio/bihagdapat/thirakhwa.ram


Glossary

Start a discussion on this article